Change the Citation Status of Prior Art

Share this article:

To change the citation status of prior art:

  1. Go to the Prior Art module.
  2. Select the Matter you wish to update. 

  1. Select the Reference(s) for which you wish to update status.
  2. Click the Set Citation Status button to manually change the status of one or more references.                         

  1. The pop-up window displays two sets of option groups. The first options are used to set the status of the reference relative to being cited in an IDS. For example, if some references are currently marked as “Not cited”, their status can be updated to show they were cited elsewhere by clicking the appropriate radio button and entering a date. 
  2. The second options are used to set whether the examiner has considered the reference. Note: Changing the Considered By Examiner status will not, by itself, affect the IDS citation status. The option groups are independent.
  3. Click the Set button when finished.

Each option is detailed further below:

Don't Change Citation Status - Checking this option prevents any changes to the IDS citation status of the checked references. Use this option if you wish to only change the “Considered By Examiner” status in the section option group. 

Note Yet Cited - Checking this option will update the checked references to show as not having been cited before. For example, if these references were previously marked as having been cited in another IDS or by the examiner, the “Not yet cited” option will remove this association and free these references up for being cited down the road.

Note: References that were cited in an AppColl generated IDS cannot be manually updated to show something else. The only way to show that one or more references are no longer cited in an AppColl generated IDS is to delete the IDS from AppColl. Further, references cannot be manually updated to show they were cited in an AppColl generated IDS. Such references will be properly updated when they are selected for inclusion when creating an IDS within AppColl. 

Citation not Required - Checking this option will update the checked references to show that they do not need to be cited in the future. This will update the Cite Count column from the main Prior Art screen to excluded these references from the count. Click here for more details on this option. 

Previously Cited (not in AppColl) - Checking this option will update the checked references to show they were previously cited in IDS outside of AppColl. An IDS date is required to show the date of the IDS. This will update the Cite Count column from the main Prior Art screen to exclude these references from the count. 

Cited by Examiner - Checking this option will update the checked references to show they were cited by an Examiner. A cite date is required to show the date the references were cited by the Examiner. This will update the Cite Count column from the main Prior Art screen to exclude these references from the count. 

Don't Change Examiner Consideration Status - Checking this option prevents any changes to the Examiner Consideration status of the checked references. Use this option if you wish to only change the IDS citation status in the first option group. 

Not Considered by Examiner - Checking this option marks the checked references as not considered by the examiner. 

Considered by Examiner - Checking this option marks the checked references as considered by the examiner.